Evaluation

Knowing many friends who had first generation parents and grew up as second generation immigrants was quite helpful in understanding and thoughtfully thinking about the beautiful plot of this story. Many students have the tough task of trying to grow up in a predominately American school while also trying to balance the cultural demnds of their parents and their families. It is quite difficult living between two different cultures and this is something many of us do not realize or even think about. Amina has the demands of memorizing prayers for an upcoming competition while also trying to decipher whether or not practicing piano and singing are "acceptable" in the Pakistani culture. When Amina's place of worship is burnt down at the end of the story, it is a reminder to all of us that although America should be based on the outstanding principles of diversity, freedom and justice, this is not always the case. This need for diverse acceptance in our world is still an ongoing battle. The author does a lovely job of bringing to light this important concern.